
Because it is snowing––again––today seems like a perfect day to tell you about this shepherd’s pie. But first, I think, I should tell you about the cookbook I made it from.
Cooking with Shelburne Farms is one of those cookbooks that fully transports you to a place. In this case, by cracking the spine we travel to a large old farm in Vermont. We meet foragers who know how to find the best wild mushrooms, we see “caramel-colored cows with soft, patient dark eyes” milked by schoolchildren on a school trip. Flipping the pages, you can practically feel a plaid blanket over your lap and a crackling fire at your side. For a girl in a one-bedroom apartment in a gray urban landscape, this is bucolic catnip like none other. The recipes offer up page after page of lamb and rabbit, maple syrup in granola, on scallops, honeyed apple tea bread and fine aged Vermont cheddar. Pretty much the cookbook embodiment of a warm heart and a thermos full of hot apple cider, it is the coziest cookbook I own.
I’ve had my eye on this shepherd’s pie recipe for years, but I finally had the opportunity to make it one cold Friday night last month. We were having date night at home, and I had plenty of time to go about the separate components of the recipe–brown the lamb, mash the cheddar potatoes, caramelize a pile of onions–while drinking a glass of red wine and listening to Nina Simone.
When I cook something that I’d potentially like to feature on the blog, Sebastian and I have a unofficial judgment process. We each get situated with napkins, salt, and forks. We take a couple bites. If he turns to me first, this is a good sign. This means he approves heartily. But if I have to turn to him and ask what he thinks, it usually means it’s something I like more than he does. Put another way, it’s healthy and he can tell. If I don’t turn to him, and he doesn’t turn to me, and we just eat in silence watching C.J. rule the press room and Sam bumble around, the recipe silently falls to the cutting room floor, never to be seen again.
Sebastian turned to me immediately when I served him this shepherd’s pie and said it was one of the best things I’ve ever made, right up there with that tart from this fall and those scallops from last spring. One for the annals! The multi-step process makes this weekend fare for blustery cold nights and fierce, post-snowshoeing appetites. But the richly delicious results make it well worth the effort. I’d venture to say that this recipe, if you’re looking for a reason to keep slogging through the snow and slush, is a reason to love winter. Would be brilliant with a toasty English ale.
Continue reading “Shepherd’s Pie with Caramelized Onions and Cheddar Mash” »